Dispatches #4 How Does an Institution Emerge? Field Notes on Shaping Conditions Part III – Parallel Realities

Melisa Sabancı Tapan, Founder, Gate 27

A note to the reader: as I continue these dispatches, I am not writing about conditions in any particular order. I am following the order in which experiences allow me to notice them. I develop this series of writings in collaboration with artificial intelligence. I begin by sharing my observations, thoughts, and experiences through conversations with AI. I then revisit, edit, and deepen the resulting text through my own perspective and lived experience. In this sense, these writings emerge from a collaborative process of reflection and writing, bringing together my personal experiences and the possibilities offered by AI.

After almost a year away from art fairs, I found myself returning to them in Paris.

Asia NOW, Design Miami and then Art Basel… I also had the chance to visit the Fondation Cartier pour l’art contemporain, a beautiful modular building connecting the past and the future with such elegance. Inside the fairs, the atmosphere was hopeful, but the excitement felt somewhat different to me.

At the Grand Palais, I found myself encountering familiar names repeatedly. Richter, Calder, Baselitz, Lee Ufan, Picasso, Mondrian… Yet what struck me wasn’t simply the recurrence of established artists, but how increasingly similar some galleries’ presentations felt. At moments, I struggled to distinguish one gallery’s perspective from another. I began wondering whether commercial uncertainty might be encouraging a convergence toward familiar names, recognizable aesthetics, larger iterations of established works, and more predictable narratives.

Of course, these were impressions rather than conclusions. Still, they left me wondering: when galleries seek to minimize risk, might they also risk losing some of what makes their perspectives distinctive?

There was an extraordinary amount to see, yet surprisingly little stayed with me. There were too many works, too many people, too much movement, and too little room to contemplate. Or perhaps something in my own relationship with art fairs has been changing.

Looking back, I realized that what stayed with me most happened around the fairs rather than within them. Visiting Thaddaeus Ropac’s home in Paris was one of those moments. Seeing people I love, meeting new ones, and having the opportunity to understand how someone whose taste I deeply admire lives with art.

What I noticed was how personal his relationship with the works was. Each seemed to carry a memory, an encounter, a collaboration, or a story from his journey with an artist. The collection felt like an extension of relationships built over time. 

It made me think of our own collection at Gate 27. Different in scale and nature, of course, yet deeply personal to us. The works contributed by our residents carry memories of the time we shared, the conversations we had, and the creative journeys we witnessed. Each represents more than an artwork; it holds a connection to someone who became part of Gate 27’s story. I find it particularly inspiring when collections become a kind of living memory, preserving not only artistic practices but the human relationships surrounding them.

Another experience that stayed with me was at the Fondation Cartier, where Ibrahim Mahama’s own practice was shown together with other artists and collectives. Mahama’s works merged traditional craftsmanship, industrial materials, and traces of Ghana’s economic history. I listened to a young Ghanaian architect, Courage Dzidula Kpodo, speak about his country’s architectural history and its relationship with economic transformation. Through archival postcards, photographs, and the reconstruction of part of a building, he invited us into a world I knew very little about. It is incredible to think how one discipline, in this case architecture, can reveal the relationship between agricultural wealth, aspirations for modernity, and the ways a society chooses to represent itself! It is through curiosity and interest, our ability to pause and listen to these diverse perspectives, that I have discovered layers of meaning that I might have otherwise overlooked. 

The Fondation Cartier itself stayed with me just as much as the works it housed. Reimagined by Jean Nouvel through a process that began over a decade ago, the historic building now contains a remarkable modular architecture, with moving platforms that allow the space to transform according to the needs of different exhibitions. Beyond the considerable financial resources, I found myself thinking about the vision, the right people, the long-term commitment, and the patience required to bring such an idea into existence, as well as the philosophy embedded in the architecture itself: a space designed to adapt to art, rather than asking art to adapt to the space.

Meanwhile, Paris was uneasy. Demonstrations, damaged streets, sounds rising from outside at night, and restrictions affecting parts of the city. People seeking to make their voices heard, scenes of destruction, and international collectors moving through galleries. Different people, different experiences, different concerns, all unfolding within the same city.

And then, almost comically, the weather joined in. One moment I was walking in the sunshine, the next I was being showered with sand, dirt, wind, and rain. I remember a young woman selling cookies from a food truck. Her beautiful display suddenly soaked. Somehow, that moment stayed with me. The voices from the streets, the tinkling wine glass, and the whirling rain all seemed to belong to the same city.

I began thinking about these parallel realities occupying the same physical space. The uncomfortable contradiction isn’t the existence of such different realities. We’ve lived with those contradictions for a long time. What’s more unsettling is how easily we can become absorbed in one reality while losing sight of the others.

Not because anyone should feel guilty for enjoying art, beauty, or comfort. Nor because we can reasonably expect everyone to remain attentive to everything happening around them. But because what we exclude from our attention may still shape the conditions we all share. 

Of course, appearing unaware does not necessarily mean being indifferent. We cannot know the extent of another person’s awareness simply by observing a passing moment. It also made me think about the institutions that create these spaces. What does it mean for a cultural institution to remain connected to its surroundings while preserving its own purpose and independence? Remaining attentive doesn’t always require taking a position. Sometimes, it may simply mean helping people stay informed and navigate the realities unfolding around them. After all, institutions themselves need the conditions to remain independent, just as the people within them need the freedom to create.

I keep returning to the idea of conditions.

Paris has built extraordinary conditions for art to be exhibited, collected, and preserved. But has it built equally strong conditions for art to be created? 

Paris also reminded me that conditions do not exist in isolation. What is being made possible? For whom? And what might remain outside our field of attention? And this made me question our own practice, too.

At Gate 27, Creating Conditions means making room for what has not yet emerged. Rather than prescribing outcomes, we seek to enable the time, space, and interdisciplinary encounters from which curiosity, experimentation, and new possibilities can develop. We try to make room for what precedes the artwork: the possibility of encountering unfamiliar perspectives, and the opportunity to develop ideas without knowing exactly where they will lead.

Conditions aren’t merely what enables us to flourish individually. They must also make room for the existence of others. Yet recognizing another’s reality does not mean accepting every action taken within it. The freedom to express ourselves and to disagree does not give us the right to harm, manipulate, or take advantage of others. Making room for one another also means respecting their autonomy, dignity, and vulnerability.

Imagine a young artist presenting work inside the Grand Palais and another young person, elsewhere in the city, trying to make their voice heard. Their circumstances, aspirations, and choices may be entirely different. Yet they may share something fundamental.

The desire to be seen. To have agency. To believe that their existence, expressions, and actions can matter. And while these aspirations deserve recognition, the ways in which we pursue them matter, too. Some conditions are mutually reinforcing. Others are incompatible.

What happens when one person’s flourishing depends upon excluding, exploiting, manipulating, or harming someone else? 

In the previous chapters, I explored the conditions that allow us to trust an invitation, arrive somewhere with a sense of presence, and become attentive to the world and people around us.

Paris brought another question into focus.

Does being aware of our own reality mean we are equally capable of recognizing the realities of others?

And what conditions allow different lives, perspectives, and experiences to coexist, while making room for one another without compromising the freedom to be ourselves?